Criteria for Evaluating Media Violence Essay - 1530 Words

No Universal Criteria for Evaluating Media Violence In a famous speech in 1995, Bob Dole, in an effort to gain more conservative support for his impending Republican Presidential Nomination, unleashed a damning indictment of the movie industry, seemingly unprovoked and somewhat puzzling. (Lacayo) Doles speech and especially the rebuttals to it raise many questions central to the debate over violence in film: is violence destructive to impressionable viewers, is violence critical to the success of the industry, does violence have aesthetic value, who decides what is violent, and if something is found to be violent, should it be banned? By going beyond Doles speech to carefully examine these questions, it is found that†¦show more content†¦Taking this into account, it is no coincidence that Dole selected The Lion King, Forrest Gump, and True Lies, all huge money earners, as his films that represent exemplary family films. (Lacayo) Viewed purely as an industry, violent content is vital to the success of current feature films; to bacco and alcohol companies produce and sell products that are proven to have negative effects, yet are allowed to continue selling. There is no concrete evidence regarding the effects of violent content in film, so how could an entire industry be penalized for speculation. However, to view this situation in terms of money only would seem cold-hearted, so other variables must be taken into account. One such variable would be the question of whether film violence has actual aesthetic value, specifically if it has artistic worth. One would be hard pressed to argue that violence is not entertainment, the high grosses and popularity these films generate disprove that theory at its core, at least from the standpoint of the public. Why do people watch scenes of extreme violence if not to be entertained? Perhaps people watch violence for its cathartic value, releasing emotion in a healthy manner by allowing the characters onscreen to act out their personal, as well as the audiences emotions. Or possibly, people watch for the stimuli they receive by watching such hyper-kinetic action. Maybe people watch to admire the stunts and special effectsShow MoreRelatedCorrelation Of Media Violence And Adhd Critique997 Words   |  4 PagesThe Correlation of Media Violence and Children’s ADHD Critique This particular study was executed to bring insight into if whether or not violent media and attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD)-related behaviors were related due to a specific gene in the body. The researchers took a sample from a previous study, Generation R, which examined the environmental and genetic elements resulted from the growth, health, and development of children. After meeting all the requirements, the subpopulationRead MoreMedia And Education On Children s Media1240 Words   |  5 PagesMedia and Education Parents can help to guide their children s media experience by offering the educational media programs as well as the non-electronic formats such as newspapers, books, board games, and watching television with them. Additionally, by putting the questionable contents into context and teaching kids about advertising can be greatly contributed to their media literacy. However, there is a strong relationship between media and education, so parents need to set their children’s limitsRead MoreIn this era of globalization, news reporting is no longer just a means of communications, but it1100 Words   |  5 Pagesthe tradition of being distant and detached (Bell 1997), which he criticizes â€Å"for focusing with the circumstances of violence, such as military formations, weapons, strategies, maneuvers and tactics† (Gilboa 2009, p. 99). Therefore it is the aim of this essay to explain whether it is ethical for reporters to practice what Martin Bell calls the Journalism of Atta chment by evaluating its major points and its counterarguments, and assessing other notions of journalism such as peace journalism. ToRead MoreWatching Tv Makes You Smarter1392 Words   |  6 Pagesbelieves that even bad T.V. is good T.V. because it teaches real world situations. This is where I believe the negative impact of the exposure of T.V. comes into play, because shows with high levels of violence could lead to the viewer reenacting the seen behavior; this goes for not only violence but other things as well. He also refers to a show that he considers nourishing; the finished series of 24, that â€Å"you have to pay attention, make inferences, track shifting social relationships† (JohnsonRead MoreMartin Luther King s Letter From Birmingham Jail1860 Words   |  8 Pagesstatement by clergymen whom apposed King’s nonviolent methods of resistance to continuous issues of racism occurring in Birmingham, Alabama. As expressed by King and described in his text, civil disobedience should meet certain criteria to be considered so. One of these criteria is that the law being disobeyed should be unj ust. Also, according to King, this direct action should be non-violent, as this was the basis of his teachings. Furthermore, the individual should be aware of consequences, and willinglyRead MoreMedia Representation of Gender Roles1954 Words   |  8 PagesHistorically, social and feminist scholars have focused on media representations of gender roles and how they affect the lived experiences of women (Green, 2013; Soulliere, 2006). Gender is widely considered to be a cultural rather than strictly biological creation, and it is often constructed and represented through popular culture media such as advertisements, magazines, and television (Soulliere, 2006). While women have made great strides in expanding the culturally acceptable definition of femininityRead MoreTough Guy Case Study Essays2046 Words   |  9 Pagesout of his way to discredit other while never admitting his own indiscretions. Physical violence in the workplace when exercised by throwing objects at other employees instills fear of one’s personal security. Visible temper tantrums combined with deceit, distrust, verbal lashings breaks down communication opportunities, which exemplified his unwillingness to listen to others. In order to identify criteria for an effective solution it is necessary to explore many possible scenarios some of whichRead MoreBullying And Its Effect On Mental Health2093 Words   |  9 Pagesconnection between bullying and mental health. Design: An integrated review of literature that was published between 2005 and 2014 Data sources: OVID (CINAHL, PsychiINFO) Review methods: An integrated review was conducted Results: 10 articles met criteria for inclusion in this Integrative Research Review. All of the articles reviewed did substantiate a connection on some level between bullying and negative effects on mental health. Conclusions: The findings of the articles suggest that bullyingRead MoreAre Free Elections Necessary to Have a Democracy?1997 Words   |  8 Pagescertain characteristics in order to understand democratization more critically. The purpose of this essay is to examine four countries in the central and eastern Europe region with democratic criteria and determine the legitimacies of these countries. The first section of this essay will examine the two criteria of the principles of democratic government that are chosen to evaluate each of the four countries in central and eastern Europe and the scale that will be used in the evaluation stage. The secondRead MoreRacial Profiling : Chicago 12 Essay3081 Words   |  13 PagesChicago Loyola University Chicago Introduction Racial profiling is a discriminatory act committed by law enforcement officials in which individuals are targeted and discriminated against based on race, religion, culture or any criteria which defines a person. Racial profiling is based around the suspicion of crime where officers turn to designated characteristics they believe to be associated with certain groups of people that commit misconducts. It is a major problem in Chicago